Clapham Journal

Spiraling Upward to Approach Mastery: Singapore Math, Part Two

For Part One of our Singapore series, click here

In the 1960s, educational theorist and cognitive psychologist Jerome Bruner articulated the concept of the spiral curriculum: an approach to teaching that reinforces student comprehension through revisiting concepts at particular intervals across a period of time. 

Jerome Bruner

Thanks to Bruner, the spiral of reinforcement is a standard approach to conceptual mastery across a variety of disciplines. It may even be true that most curricula spirals, but not always in the same way. Some math curricula, for example, may have students working with clocks on Monday, addition and subtraction on Wednesday, and money on Friday, and then begin the cycle again the following week. Moving rapidly between concepts may maintain student interest, but it won’t necessarily allow the opportunity to work slowly enough to develop genuine comprehension. Some educational researchers refer to this as a horizontal spiral, much like a landline telephone cord.

Some math curriculum moves like a horizontal spiral throughout the week.

Contrary to the pacing of other math curricula, Singapore Math moves on a less hurried, ascendant vertical spiral. Students spend more time working with particular concepts in each level of math, but as they do, they are revisiting principles they have previously learned to deepen comprehension. This is a vertical spiral, similar to a spiral staircase. 

Some researchers also refer to the ascendant spiral as a strand curriculum, as it integrates various concepts like strands throughout the spiral. This approach emphasizes mastery of foundational math concepts over exposure. It allows students more time to practice various operations, increasing their accuracy and speed.  

Example: A screen grab from the Scope & Sequence of US 2022 Primary Mathematics (our Singapore Math curriculum at Clapham). Fractions are introduced in second grade, but the spiral returns to and deepens fraction concepts across several years.

At Clapham, teachers are constantly discussing math concepts with their classes, allowing them to orient themselves on the spiral. “What do we know? What do we need to know to find the solution? What do you notice about the last three problems on the board? How are they alike or different? Can you think of another way to find the solution? What is being asked of the statement 1/2 of 3/4? Can you demonstrate this question?”

Discussions like this encourage students to retrieve past methods of problem solving and to apply them in new ways to new problems. Of course, they also provide valuable information to the teacher, who is constantly gauging student comprehension and making individual adjustments based on how well each student understands a concept. This is one of the advantages of a our small class sizes at Clapham; teachers have more time to devote to each student individually and to customize their discussions or pace to different levels of understanding. 

A screen shot from singaporemath.com. The word "revision" in the spiral refers to revisiting or reviewing and building upon previously learned concepts.
Spiral in Action: 
Consider this example from our Lower School curriculum coordinator, Sally Woodhouse, and our Class Two teacher, Andree Escobar:
 
In Class One, students learn to add numbers one through ten: 
     5 + 4 = 9
 
In Class Two, they move to adding tens, then hundreds:
   5 tens + 4 tens = 9 tens 
   (50 + 40 = 90)
 
This lays the foundation for adding numbers like:
   15 + 4
Students can think of 15+4 as:
   1 ten + 5 ones + 4 ones
 
After this, students add larger numbers:
   5 hundreds + 4 hundreds = 9 hundreds  
   (500 + 400 = 900 )
   The revision of concepts can be noted in adding 531 + 426:
 
Throughout the years, students build on what they know of 5 + 4 but now are working with tens, hundreds, and so on. Class Three begins the year adding in the thousands. 
 

It is a common misconception that Singapore is a mastery curriculum rather than a spiral curriculum. As Clapham faculty member Andree Escobar explains, “It’s both.” It is true that Singapore does not spiral as quickly or briefly as other math curricula might. However, Singapore’s longer, more in-depth upward spiral ultimately serves to deepen student comprehension and allow for more time with each math concept. This type of spiral is more conducive to mastering foundational concepts and strengthening student accuracy, understanding, confidence, and problem-solving ability. 

Loading